Daphne and Mingo, a hearing student on her floor, organize a dorm triathlon to compete for control over the best bathroom. Bay and Toby try to hide that Bay is a convicted felon in the hopes of getting her art accepted into a showcase.
Toby told Lily, Lily told Melody, and Melody starts an official investigation. Soon everyone knows what happened between Bay and Tank or think they do. People blame themselves, Tank, Bay, or just try to help. The situation just spirals out of control. Bay and Tank just want it all to go away.
Bay struggles being in Art School due to her incident with Tank. Daphne starts questioning her relationship with Mingo, while also trying to help Toby confront Lily about her pregnancy. John faces financial crisis.
With Mingo's help, Daphne holds a fundraiser to help support a sign-language school in Mexico. Bay is livid when a student starts using her art to sell crude t-shirts. Regina deals with the repercussions of digging through Eric's past. Meanwhile, Toby and Lily have to make difficult decisions about their future.
Bay has her first gallery show ever and Emmett returns and so does Quinn and Craig. Regina tries to convince Eric to go back to Atlanta with Will. John gets arrested and they all go to the hospital. Bay and Daphne ponder their future.