My Fake Fiancé (2009 TV Movie)
Jennifer mentions the show and having Valerie Bertinelli for a sister.
Vince describes the show while fabricating his life story.
Similar title. Two strangers are brought together to win money by convincing everyone of their fake engagement and wedding.
The gangsters talk about watching the show as they search Vince's house.
Mel poses as Joe's fiancee. He then says "Look at you, my fake freaking fiancee" This is actually a movie they had done together where they had faked an engagement together.