Trampas and David Sutton are sent to an auction in Durango, Colorado to purchase and return with a Galloway bull. Clay wants to send The Virginian but he can't leave so he vouches for Trampas and suggests adding David in case they have to drive the bull back. After arriving in Durango, David bumps into Martha Carson who is trying to avoid the romantic overtures of the big hulk "Tiny" Morgan. During the encounter Martha asks David to be engaged to her until Tiny who David mistakes for a diminutive store clerk leaves town. Trampas knows Tiny and tries to warn David but ultimately takes advantage of the situation at David's expense. The charade turns into a massive problem for both of them as word spreads and Tiny decides to stay for their wedding. Martha's landlady wants to give them a bridal shower while Tiny trails David to make sure he treats Martha properly. After taking a trip to a jewelry store to buy rings, David accidentally takes a ring resulting in the Sheriff putting him in ...