Kellie resists Drew's proposed commitment to her, so he enlists the help of her parents who bicker constantly and bitterly. When they learn he got Kellie pregnant, they aren't pleased with the idea of him as her husband.
When Drew's dad dies, Drew makes the funeral arrangements and buys the coffin from the Internet, but a coffin themed on the band Kiss arrives instead of a Marines one. Kellie tells Drew he's not ready for fatherhood.
After promising Kellie he won't drink during her pregnancy, Drew goes partying with the guys. Oswald loses a toe in an escalator ride and uses the settlement to buy a portion of the Warsaw. Mimi arranges deliveries from the package man.
Drew sees bus-driver Tony doze off and knock over parking meters. Conflicted, Drew arranges him to get a job at the store. When Tony finds out Drew reported him, he retaliates by stealing his online-senior-pharmacy idea.
Mimi warns Drew to not have sex with Kellie after she gives birth. At baby-care class, Drew becomes turned off by the thought of the baby's presence. The Warsaw's hot new waitress makes Kellie feel unattractive.
Mimi and a gay couple have been swapping babysitting and she gets Drew to play father figure for Gus when the couple comes to dinner. Drew plays a role in their breakup which stops the swap, so Mimi pushes him to get them to reconcile.
Mimi's stayover hookup Tyler insists on sticking around and tells Mimi he's painting art although he's just loafing. After unsuccessfully bribing him to leave, Drew connects with a hired enforcer Lewis knows. Drew only asks him to scare Tyler.
Drew gives Gus his old wood-burning kit for his birthday, which is blamed when Mimi's house burns down. When Drew discovers that they're living in the Neverending Store warehouse, he convinces them to move into his home.
As tension builds as Mimi and Drew irritate each other sharing the house, an insurance rep (Wayne Knight) is reviewing Mimi's claim on her burnt house. When their stories don't mesh, the rep plans to interview Gus so they coach him to lie.
Lewis is depressed due to breaking up with his girlfriend so Drew and Oswald take him to a strip club where he suffers a breast related injury. Drew gets caught lying to his girlfriend about the club when Lewis sues the dancer.
Drew receives a letter from Steve with a check to help since Mimi lives with him. He wants back with Mimi but she is dating Larry so Drew arranges a meeting. Then a one-night stand Steve had in his world travel arrives and Steve tells Mimi.
Drew is fired from Neverending Store and has a plan to re-open Winfred-Lauder but needs a backer. He contacts former boss Nigel Wick whose father-in-law owns the Christian TV network and real estate. They make a deal but what will it cost?
Drew wants to marry before baby is born. Kellie accepts but after an engagement party goes into labor on way to city hall for the ceremony. At the hospital Drew recruits a priest giving last rites. Then a great thank you to the show's fans.