The "antique" spectacles that Kirk sells to the antiques dealer when they first arrive in San Francisco are described as 18th century. After telling Kirk how much he will pay for them the dealer says they would have been worth more if the lenses were intact. The glasses have plastic ear pieces and bridge pieces, which they most certainly wouldn't have had in the 18th century.
Star Trek IV- The Voyage Home officially takes place in 2286... and 1986. Star Trek II- The Wrath Of Khan began on March 22nd, 2285 (Stardate 8130.3), Admiral Kirk's 52nd birthday. The events between the beginning of the Enterprise's training cruise on the 23rd of March to the Enterprise returning to Space Dock after her battle with the USS Reliant, the detonation of the Genesis device and the birth of a new planet where the Matara nebula used to be, Spock's death and funeral, the transfer of Savik and David Marcus to the USS Grisom and the rescue of the Reliant's crew members left on Ceti Alpha V was roughly one or two weeks. Another several days went by between when Kirk learned that McCoy was holding Spock's Katra at the expense of his mental health, stealing the Enterprise (Stardate 8210.3) to return to Genesis and the fal-tor-pan ritual on Vulcan to transfer Spock's Katra back into his newly resurrected body. When Kirk, McCoy, Scotty, Uhura, Chekov and Sulu have agreed to return to Earth on the newly christened "HMS Bounty" to face court-martial, they have been exiled on Vulcan for three months. It should still be 2285.
When Scotty is typing on the computer in the plexiglass factory and his hands are shown, the sound effects of typing do not match up with his hands, which are moving much slower. In addition, there is no way a single keystroke as demonstrated by Scotty could create the level of graphics shown on the 1986-vintage Macintosh computer used in the scene.
When Spock tells Gillian that Gracie is pregnant, she brakes the truck and we hear a squealing sound indicating that the tires have locked-up and are skidding on the road. However, the scene immediately cuts to a side shot of the truck stopping and the wheels are not locked - the truck comes to a gentle stop.
In the tour group when Kirk and Spock first see the whales, there is a 20th century US Naval officer who doesn't remove his cap during the entire tour, even downstairs at the viewing area. Uncovering when indoors is such a basic uniform wear regulation that a first-week recruit at boot camp does it instinctively; a commissioned officer in public certainly wouldn't forget to do it.
Scotty asks Dr Nichols how thick a 10 foot by 60 foot sheet of plexiglass would have to be to withstand the pressure of 18,000 cubic feet of water. The pressure from water is determined by its "head", or depth, not by the volume. As an engineer Scotty should be aware of this.
When asked if the glasses he is pawning are the gift Dr. McCoy gave him, Kirk responds that "they will be again," thus seemingly setting up an ontological paradox: Kirk is suggesting that the very same pair he is selling will be bought by McCoy, given to him in the future, and then sold again in the past. The glasses Kirk is selling are broken, however, so McCoy would have bought the intact pair. It would be an earlier version of the same glasses, but the broken pair would be bought by someone else, if at all.
When McCoy tries to discuss the afterlife with Spock, Spock states that they can't because there is no point of reference. McCoy then complains, "So I have to die in order to discuss death?" - McCoy DID, in fact, die, and then get "repaired" by alien technology in Star Trek: The Original Series: Shore Leave, which both characters should remember.
After Spock nerve pinches the punk, the punk's head falls on the radio and probably hits the off switch, killing the music. Kirk resumes normal speech, but Spock is still speaking louder than necessary.
Dr. Taylor gestures toward some orca sculptures while making a comment about whales. Despite the "killer whale" misnomer, orca's are not whales, but rather a type of dolphin. As an expert, she would know that.
Right after the Bounty has landed in the park and the trash men start to flee, some of the trash cans nearest the truck are full to or nearly to the tops. But as the truck drives off, those cans appear to be empty.
When Dr. Taylor drops off Spock at the park, the ignition switch of the Chevy pickup is shown in the "off" position, yet engine idling sound continues and there is no sound of the engine starting up again.
As the Bounty starts going to warp for time travel, we see Spock's hand-held display fall off the console to the desk, and there's a close up of it landing. A long-shot of the bridge, including the area in front of Spock's console doesn't show the hand-held.
During Dr. Taylor's conversation with Kirk and Spock in the pickup truck, three women (dressed in pink, purple, and denim) are briefly seen through the passenger-side window walking along. Thirty seconds later, the same three women are seen through the driver-side window, walking in the opposite direction.
After Scott makes Kirk aware that their trip through time has drained the dilithium "Klingon crystals" that power their ship, Kirk and Spock discusses how toxic and dangerous 20th century photons are to handle, even so it was less than half a year ago that Spock died from exposure to 23rd century photons while repairing the main energizer so that the Enterprise could warp to a safe distance just before Genesis detonated.
The probe left the Saratoga and the Yorktown powerless and adrift in space. They remained powerless for at least 3 hours. When the probe left the vicinity of Earth later in the movie, all power sources on Earth spacedock and the planet itself came back to life immediately.
When Sulu accidentally turns on the windshield wipers of the helicopter, the wipers were broken so a grip had to move the wipers manually. Look closely and you can see his finger holding on to the blade as it moves back and forth.
Just before Spock checks the bus map at a stop, you can see several crew members are visible through a large glass window of a restaurant - one of them even clearly wears a "Star Trek IV" security badge, and all are wearing walkie-talkies.
When the tour group is viewing the whales from above and it it sprays water from it's blow hole there is a small amount of smoke (you can tell the difference from water spray by the way it drifts out) that trails out after the initial spray possibly from the charge used to propel the water from the prop whale blow hole.
Kirk and Spock are seen walking as Dr. Taylor drives up. She asks where they are going, Kirk replies "Back to San Francisco." The scene is shot in the Marina District of San Francisco. Kirk and Spock are already in San Francisco, Sausalito is on the other side of the Golden Gate Bridge which is behind them. While it is possible that Kirk may simply made a mistake being from the future, Dr. Taylor later even mocks him at dinner saying that they couldn't even get back to San Francisco without a lift.
When Kirk and the crew first exit the ship after landing in Golden Gate Park, Uhura says the whales are on a heading of 283 degrees (Spock repeats this heading at the bus stop). 283 degrees from Golden Gate Park heads straight out to sea without passing near Sausalito.
When Sulu plots a course to pick up the whales, Admiral Kirk orders full impulse power. Sulu states an ETA of 12 minutes. From San Francisco to the Bering Sea is about 2825 miles. Full impulse power is listed as 1/4 the speed of light, or approximately 167 million MPH. With these figures, the trip should take about 0.06 seconds, not 12 minutes.
When Dr. Gillian Taylor picks up Kirk and Spock while they are walking into San Francisco, you can clearly see that the street is actually a parking lot. The stall markers are on still on the pavement.
Ships in the opening sequence that are affected by the probe lose power and come to an almost complete stop. In the vacuum of space, air friction does not exist, so they should keep going the same speed they were before.
The whale tank aboard the Bounty appears to go from floor to ceiling, which wouldn't allow the whales the ability to breathe. As air-breathing mammals, they must be able to surface regularly, as the ending of the movie even stresses.
When Kirk asks Scotty how long the transporter bay is, he replies, "About 60 feet." Other units of measure throughout the movies have characters using metric units (meters, kilometers, etc) so it seems much more likely that Scotty would have said, "About 18 meters."
When the Bird of Prey is seem warping towards the Sun, the Sun is shown to glow with a pale yellow light, but in space, it would glow with a bright white light, since the Sun only appears yellow from Earth's perspective due to the atmosphere.scattering blue light.
When Kirk and his crew walk by San Francisco, Kirk looks a newspaper's 25-cent box where can be seen an issue of San Francisco Register, with the headline "Nuclear Arms Talks Stalled". Although not completely visible, time-date under the headline is marked as "Thursday, December 24, 1986". December 24 was Wednesday, not Thursday.
In this film the HMS Bounty achieves time travel by using the gravitational forces of the sun to "slingshot" it into a time-warp. This plot device is presumably taken from Star Trek: The Original Series: Tomorrow Is Yesterday. However on that occasion the USS Enterprise does not go around a normal star such as our sun, but goes around a so-called "black star". "Black star" is a 1960's name for a black hole. A black hole has a gravitational force millions of times larger than our sun and the direction the Enterprise would have needed to take would be to the center of the Milky Way galaxy, not the center of our solar system.
Scotty uses a 1986 computer to create the formula of transparent aluminum. It's impossible for a 2286 mind to use correctly a 1986 computer unless Scotty had a special preparation in 20th century's technology.
Whales give birth in tropical climates during winter and return to arctic regions during the summer. A newborn would never survive the colder temperature. Biologists specializing in whales should have known this.
The "On duty Commander" aboard the Enterprise Air Craft Carrier (i.e. U.S.S. Ranger CV-61) Stated, that their was an "Intruder in M.M.R. number 4". This is an questionable statement probably due to assumptions by some one not familiar with military terminology. M.M.R., possibly refers to "Main Missile Room" which at the time of this film (November 1986) did not exist except on paper. Though on the drawing boards was "Gerald Ford class (or Ford class, previously known as "CVN 21 class") which is a class of super-carriers currently being built to replace some of the United States Navy's existing Nimitz-class carriers." Designed originally in 1975. The first two ships, USS Gerald R Ford (CVN 78) and USS John F. Kennedy (CVN 79), will be commissioned in 2015 and 2019. The carrier(s) will be armed with the Raytheon evolved Sea Sparrow missile (ESSM), which defends against high-speed, highly maneuverable anti-ship missiles. This information most likely was classified "Top Secret" in 1986. CVN-80, U.S.S. Enterprise should be commissioned by 2025, She will be the ninth ship and the third aircraft carrier in the history of the United States Navy to bear the name. Trekkers rejoice! Magazine applies to any compartment, space, or locker that is used, or intended to be used, for the stowage of explosives or ammunition of any kind., also stowed separately from powder or fuel used to launch stated projectile(s) generally located below the main deck, and insofar as is practical, below the waterline.For safety reasons and only brought together during readiness for battle or defensive preparation(s).This is S.O.P. (Standard Operating Procedure) for many military branches. The "Big E, Grey Ghost" would not normally have had any nuclear weapons on board except in some form of transportation scenario. While a ship of the line might have defensive missiles on board as protection from airborne or surface enemy platforms. It is highly unlikely that the Enterprise would have a "Missile Room".
When Spock is being tested by the computer, some camera angles are shot through the display screens. The text when viewed from the back is still displayed forward, which can be explained as a feature of a holographic alien device from the future rather than a goof.
Chekov states that the nuclear vessel they find is called the Enterprise. While it is actually the USS Ranger (CV-61), in this film the Ranger "plays" the Enterprise, much like an actor playing a part.
The whalers speak Finnish, but they are in the Bering Sea, part of the north Pacific Ocean. As Finland has not commercially hunted whales in well over a century, the Finns may be mercenaries for Japan, which was still involved in commercial whaling in 1986.
When Dr. Gillian Taylor meets Spock and Kirk, they never reveal their names to her, as amplified by the fact that she keeps asking them both, "who are you?" The only thing that she overhears from Spock is "Admiral," as well as "Admiral" from Scotty on his communicator when they are having dinner in the pizza restaurant. Yet when Dr. Gillian Taylor discovers the whales have been taken from the institute, she drives back to the park where the spaceship is, shouting "Admiral Kirk!" How does she know his name if he never told her? We might be able to assume that he revealed it to her at some point that was not seen on screen when they were together, but the last time Kirk and Dr. Gillian Taylor see each other before she comes back shouting his name, she still asks him, "who are you?" To which he says, "Think about it," and still does not reveal his name. *** When Scotty and Kirk speak over their communicator Kirk signs off with "Kirk out," so Gillian does hear his name.
Just after Kirk and Gillian drop Spock off in the park near the cloaked Bounty, Spock is shown beaming aboard. However, Kirk is with Gillian, McCoy and Scotty are at the factory giving the formula for the transparent aluminum, Uhura and Chekov are aboard the aircraft carrier, and Sulu is dealing with the helicopter, leavning no-one on board the Bounty to operate the transporter.
During the Klingon Ambassador's argument before the Federation President, he shows footage of the destruction of the Enterprise, including footage from inside the bridge. There is no way he should have possession of either set of footage. If the Klingon Bird of Prey somehow recorded the destruction of the Enterprise, there is still the fact that the Bird of Prey is in Kirk's possession. Any footage aboard the Enterprise would have been destroyed with it.
Chekov runs through an open door from the room where he's being questioned by the government officials. That door would certainly be closed when questioning an intruder with unknown devices on a Navy ship.
Error in temporal physics, possibly inherent to the time travel sub-genre of fiction: Even if it were possible to "go into" the past of 1986, the world of Kirk and Spock and the Enterprise would have automatically not existed, and therefore, even the smallest changes they made at the Institute and their dealings with others would have created a different time-line, even if they could precisely calculate when and how to "return" to "their time," their world and everything else in the galaxy would have been completely different. It is impossible to go back in time without altering the future that follows it. Even worse, McCoy goes about flagrantly altering history by growing the old woman a new kidney, which would lead to her having years of life which could not exist in the "original" time line. Also, the Bounty's arrival squashed a trash can which thus could not continue to be used for sanitation as it would in an unaltered time line. The novelization actually explains away the paradoxes by directly stating that many of the supposed changes were actually caused by them. I.e., they had to go back in time so that the timeline would be correct.
Uhura reports that Chekov is being taken to emergency surgery, and Kirk and others go to rescue him in daylight. Yet he was captured after beaming in when Kirk and Dr Taylor were just starting their meal the previous evening. Surely if Chekov's condition was so critical as to require emergency surgery, that would not have been delayed by over 12 hours.
Spock indicates that the Probe would not respond to synthesized versions of whales, commenting that it would sound to the probe as "gibberish." However, given the fact that they are in the year 2286, would they not somewhere in all their computer and history banks have an actual recording of whales to play back for the probe, thus precluding the preposterous and impossible feat of backwards time travel? Since the probe was only listening for sounds and not a visual response, it is extremely unlikely that the Probe would not have accepted the recordings and moved on.
When McCoy and Scotty are at the computer with the manager of Plexicorp in his office the overhead lights are shown to be on yet when Madeline enters and leaves the switch to the lights next to the door is down in the off position.
When the elderly lady is being pushed in a wheelchair, happily saying, "The doctor gave me a pill and I grew a new kidney", the nurse on the left side of the screen almost trips over the wheelchair, but manages to recover.
The goof items below may give away important plot points.
Immediately after the whales' transponders are located in the Bering Sea, Gillian can be seen to mouth "How did you do that?" without sound, then she is immediately seen and heard giving the same line from another camera angle.
After the trial in which Kirk is demoted from Admiral to Captain, the crew are shown in a shuttle craft heading for the Enterprise-A. If you look closer at Kirk's uniform, he is wearing the correct rank of captain, however he is still wearing the gold pin-striping on the front of his tunic (jacket) which is part of the admiral decoration. This was removed for Star Trek V: The Final Frontier and onward.
Mr. Scott in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock is promoted to Captain of Engineering and in the USS Excalibur scenes showing the rank insignia of Captain, but at the end of Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home during the trial scene shown wearing the insignia of a Commander.
At the end when the camera pans the crew just before their pardon, Scotty wears the rank pin of a Commander. This is despite his being promoted to Captain in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, being listed in this film's credits as "Captain Montgomery Scott," and wearing Captain's pins in the next film, Star Trek V: The Final Frontier.
When the Bounty appears above the whaler, the whaler's helmsman begins spinning the wheel madly to starboard (the right). From a long shot, the whaler turns quickly. A closeup of the whaler's captain and helmsman doesn't show any movement. The sky and water behind them don't change.
When the Bounty uncloaks over the whaling ship, it's shadow can be seen over the ship in the wide shots, but in the closeups of the whaling ship, no shadow can be seen on the ship or the water around it.
The Bounty is shown hovering above the whaler with the whaler deep in its shadow. When they cut back the bridge of the whaler, they're back in the sunshine. They cut back to show the Bounty hovering over the whaler, and it is once again in shadow.
When the Bounty is descending towards the whaling ship, there is a shot of the whales immediately following a quick shot of the harpoon. At the extreme right-hand side of the underwater whale shot you can make out a diver from waist up.
The first time Kirk and the crew boomerang around the Sun to achieve time travel, the ship nearly breaks apart, with things popping and exploding on the bridge. But the second time they do the same, it appears to be a relatively smooth ride. Apparently, the second time Spock managed to calculate the ship's trajectory better than the first time. In a previous scene Kirk teaches Spock to use human intuition in order to solve the return trajectory problem. Perhaps the intuitive approach had paid off.
After they all escape, Chekov's phaser is still in the possession of the military agents that had originally arrested him. While McCoy earlier in the film airs his concern to Scotty about leaving advanced technology (Plexiglas scene) or information of same in the past, no concern is given to Chekov's phaser, which is left behind.
The crew at Starfleet HQ in San Francisco shout and point, "There, There!" as to indicate the descent of the Bounty as Kirk and crew return through the clouds, yet the cloud cover is so thick that nothing past the bridge can be seen, so how could the Admiral see the ship, let alone know that it was coming?
When the Bounty appears above the whaler, the whaler's helmsman begins spinning the wheel madly to starboard (the right.) He continues spinning the wheel long after the wheel would have stopped as the rudder came up to the stops.